The MLB Prospects Bubble: Unveiling the Ones Who Almost Made the Cut
Each year, the highly anticipated top 100 MLB prospect ranking by Keith Law sparks curiosity and debate. But here's where it gets controversial: the players who just missed the list. These prospects, though not in the spotlight, possess immense potential and are worth keeping an eye on. This article delves into the stories of these talented individuals, providing insights into their skills, challenges, and what sets them apart.
Dax Kilby (SS, New York Yankees): The Yankees' first pick in the 2025 draft, Kilby made a remarkable pro debut in Low A, showcasing a short and direct swing with surprising power. His exceptional contact skills and low chase rate (11.1%) are reminiscent of MLB stars. With a solid pro sample, Kilby could be an above-average player at any position.
Dylan Beavers (OF, Baltimore Orioles): After tinkering with his swing, Beavers had a breakout year in Triple-A, earning a call-up to the majors. Despite a hitch in his swing, he boasts high exit velocities and is projected as a 20-homer guy. However, his swing shape may limit his ability to hit for both average and power, a crucial skill for a corner outfielder.
Roldy Brito (IF/OF, Colorado Rockies): Brito dominated the Arizona Complex League and Low A, showcasing a strong hit tool and impressive speed. As a switch-hitter, he has shown power potential and excellent bunting skills. While his defensive skills are still developing, if he continues to rake and improve defensively, he could be a top 100 prospect next year.
Slade Caldwell (OF, Arizona Diamondbacks): Caldwell has the makings of a traditional leadoff hitter, drawing walks and showing good pitch recognition. His small strike zone and low swing rates contribute to a high OBP. Scouts question his passivity, but with solid defense and batting averages, he could be an everyday player. The Diamondbacks' promotion to High A will be a true test of his abilities.
Nathan Flewelling (C, Tampa Bay Rays): Despite underwhelming batting averages, Flewelling is a defensive standout with a high floor. His compact swing and high exit velocities, combined with extreme patience (14% chase rate), make him a real prospect. With more experience, he could become a top-tier catcher.
Jhostynxon Garcia (OF, Pittsburgh Pirates): Garcia, a former top-100 prospect, showed power but struggled with a high strikeout rate in Triple-A. His ability to make hard contact is undeniable, but swing decisions need adjustment. With a potential 20-homer floor, Garcia could be an All-Star with the right approach.
Trevor Harrison (RHP, Tampa Bay Rays): Harrison's stuff is plus, but his results in High A were disappointing. With an easy delivery and great build, his high walk rate is puzzling. With time to refine his control and add pitches, Harrison could still become a breakout star.
Johnny King (LHP, Toronto Blue Jays): King's debut in the Florida Complex League was impressive, but control issues in Low A kept him off the top 100. With a solid arsenal and the potential to fix his inconsistent delivery, King could be a top prospect next year.
Ching-Hsien Ko (OF, Los Angeles Dodgers): Ko has the tools but needs to prove himself against better pitching. His power potential is evident, but an overly passive approach hurt him in Low A. With further development, he could become a power-hitting corner outfielder.
JR Ritchie (RHP, Atlanta): Ritchie's delivery and projection are enticing, but he lacks a clear out-pitch. With an arsenal of average to above-average pitches, he could become a command-and-control specialist. However, high walk rates in Double A and Triple A keep him just outside the top 100.
Caden Scarborough (RHP, Texas Rangers): Scarborough is a strike-throwing machine with two plus pitches. With the development of a third pitch, he could become a top starter. His deceptive delivery and power generation make him a prospect to watch.
Ralphy Velazquez (1B, Cleveland Guardians): Velazquez's 2025 season was underwhelming for a first baseman. While he has plus bat speed and hits fastballs well, his breaking-ball recognition needs improvement. With a wide stance and limited flexibility, he may need to adjust his approach to reach his full potential.
These prospects, while not in the top 100, are on the cusp of greatness. Their stories remind us that the road to MLB stardom is filled with challenges and adjustments. What do you think about these players? Are there any you believe should have made the top 100? Share your thoughts and let's discuss the future of these promising talents!
